If you’re serious about baking, then you’ve probably already got strong opinions on the tools you use, and a good baking mat is one of those essentials that can make or break your baking game. I used to rely on rolls of parchment paper, thinking that its ease and affordability were unbeatable. But after diving deeper into the world of baking mats—particularly silicone mats—I quickly realized there’s so much more to consider.
I’ve tested a variety of mats over the years, from standard silicone mats to more specialized perforated versions that promise perfect crispness. But which one truly delivers the best results? To get to the bottom of it, I decided to put the top contenders to the test. I baked multiple batches of cookies using various mats, keeping the conditions identical across the board—same oven, same temperature, and same baking time.
My goal was to find out which mat performs the best across a few key factors: browning, shape retention, and texture. Whether you’re baking sugar cookies or experimenting with other treats, the right mat can elevate your results, and I’m excited to share what I’ve learned.
Best Baking Mats
Silpat Silicone Baking Mat
When it comes to silicone baking mats, Silpat is the gold standard – and for good reason! As a seasoned baker, I can attest to the exceptional performance of these mats, which are staples in many restaurant kitchens and bakeries. Made with a durable, fiberglass-reinforced, food-grade silicone blend, Silpats distribute heat evenly across the baking surface, ensuring perfectly cooked treats every time. Plus, cleaning is a breeze – simply hand wash or toss them in the dishwasher for a hassle-free experience.
Whether you’re whipping up a batch of chewy cookies, crispy granola, or even delicate bread, these mats deliver. The Silpain mesh version takes things to the next level, allowing for airflow and creating a crispy crust on bread while maintaining shape and texture on cookies. I’ve personally had amazing results using Silpats for granola – they can handle high heat with ease, and cleanup is a snap.
If I’m being picky, the only con I can think of is that Silpats can be a tad pricey compared to other silicone mats on the market. However, trust me when I say it’s worth the investment. You’ll be using these mats for years to come, and the quality is unmatched. If you’re serious about baking, Silpats are an absolute must-have. I’d recommend them to anyone – amateur or pro – looking to elevate their baking game. In short, Silpats are the ultimate baking companion – get ready to bake like a pro!
Check price from Amazon
Amazon Basics Silicone, Non-Stick Baking Mat
The Amazon Basics Silicone Baking Mat is a fantastic budget-friendly option. Oven-safe up to 480°F, it features angled corners for easy release from the pan and rolls up compactly for storage. During testing, cookies baked on this mat came out slightly crisper with a bit more variation in browning at the edges, but still delivered great results. One standout feature is how sticky the mat is on the counter, providing a stable surface for rolling dough.
What I love most is its non-stick quality—everything from cookies to sticky treats like peanut butter and jelly thumbprints lifts off easily. While it’s not dishwasher safe, cleaning is a breeze with a quick wipe. The set of two mats is perfect for baking multiple batches at once, making it ideal for beginners looking for an affordable, dependable option.
Check price from Amazon
OXO Good Grips Silicone Baking Mat
OXO is a brand I usually associate with storage containers, so I was surprised to see their Good Grips Silicone Baking Mat ranked so highly. After testing it, I can confidently say it deserves the praise. Cookies baked on this mat turned out perfectly browned and evenly spread, with a soft, moist interior—ideal if you prefer a chewy cookie over a crisp one. The mat’s food-safe silicone and fiberglass construction provide durability and structure, while the non-stick surface resists grease and residue.
Beyond cookies, I found it fantastic for making hand-pulled noodles, pasta dough, dumplings, and pie crusts. With just a little fat like oil or butter, the dough lifts easily without the need for extra flour, making a bench scraper almost unnecessary. The 11.5″ x 16.5″ size fits half-sheet pans perfectly, and it’s oven and dishwasher safe, making it a reliable, versatile kitchen companion.
Check price from Amazon
de Buyer Silicone Baking Mat
When it comes to baking, precision is key, and de Buyer’s Silicone Baking Mat is the ultimate game-changer. This ingenious tool is a masterclass in design, featuring a unique honeycomb structure that not only prevents tears but also increases flexibility. The anti-skid bottom ensures stability, so you can knead and roll with confidence. The real showstopper, however, is the circular template and incremental measurements etched onto the mat’s surface. This clever addition allows for precise pastry rolling and accurate dough slicing, making it a dream for pie and quiche enthusiasts.
I’ve found myself reaching for this mat again and again, whether I’m whipping up a quick tart or intricately layering puff pastry. The generous prep space is a bonus, providing ample room to spread out and get creative. Yes, the price tag may be steeper than some of its competitors, but trust me, this mat is an investment that will last a lifetime. Just be sure to hand wash it – no dishwasher here!
What truly sets de Buyer’s Silicone Baking Mat apart is its versatility. It’s not just a one-trick pony; it’s a multi-tasking powerhouse that seamlessly transitions from pastry rolling to dough portioning.
Check price from Amazon
Kitzini Silicone Baking Mat Set
The BPA-free, food-grade silicone construction ensures a non-stick surface that eliminates the need for baking sprays or oils, making my baking life so much easier. The added fiberglass mesh provides the perfect balance of flexibility and stability, allowing me to effortlessly roll out dough without any sticking or tearing.
In my testing, these mats performed flawlessly. Sugar cookies baked evenly and consistently, with minimal effort required to release them from the mat. Although the mat did slide slightly on the countertop, I had no trouble rolling and rerolling dough. One thing to note is that the mats are only oven-safe up to 400 degrees F, so if you’re looking for a mat that can handle higher temperatures, this might not be the best fit.
What I love most about these mats is their ease of cleaning – a quick toss in the dishwasher and they’re good as new! The silicone is also incredibly durable, withstanding multiple uses without showing any signs of wear. Compared to other mats on the market, the Kitzini set stands out for its exceptional quality and affordability.
Check price from Amazon
Folksy Super Kitchen Baking Mat
Its generous 28″ x 20″ size provides plenty of space for rolling out dough or crafting large batches of cookies. The non-slip design is a standout feature, as it securely grips the countertop, making baking sessions smoother and frustration-free. We love the printed measurement guides, especially the circles for pie crusts, which make achieving consistent results so much easier.
Cleaning is simple—dough and flour wipe off effortlessly—but its large size can be tricky to manage in a standard sink. While the mat is advertised as non-stick, wetter doughs may need a light dusting of flour to prevent sticking.
Durable and versatile, the mat rolls up neatly for compact storage with its handy elastic band. Overall, it’s a must-have for avid bakers looking to streamline their workflow and protect their countertops.
Check price from Amazon
DANIA & DEAN Baking Mat
Made from premium food-grade silicone reinforced with fiberglass, it boasts double the thickness (0.7mm) of standard mats, ensuring longevity and resistance to wrinkling or degradation. Its non-slip bottom firmly grips the counter, providing a stable surface for rolling, cutting, and pounding dough. The non-stick surface works well with light flouring, making cleanup a breeze—just rinse with soapy water or toss it in the dishwasher.
The printed measurements, including pizza-sized circles, are a great feature, offering precision for bakers. It folds neatly for storage and dries quickly after washing. The mat is heat-resistant (up to 450°F), suitable for ovens, microwaves, and freezers.
However, wetter doughs tend to stick more than expected, requiring extra flour for smooth use. Despite this, it’s a durable and safe option for both home cooks and professional chefs alike.
Check price from Amazon
